All perfume samples are authentic fragrances that Surrender to Chance, Topeka, KS, has rebottled into smaller sample and decant sizes, repackaged and distributed. Surrender to Chance has no affiliation, connection or association with the manufacturers or brand owners of the perfumes.
Thornapple launched in 2026 and was inspired by the occult associations of the thorn apple. Inspired by one of nature’s most captivating outlaws, Thornapple captures the fascination of a plant suspended between beauty and danger, dream and delirium. Verdant leaves, saffron and an uncanny apple accord surrender to black tea, dark plum, frankincense, oakmoss and musk. It’s a fragrance of forbidden beauty. Alluring but dangerous. It features top notes (The Temptation) of apple accord, green leaves, cardamom and saffron; middle notes (The Delirium) of black tea, dark plum, labdanum and frankincense; and base notes (The Spell) of oakmoss, vetiver, ambered woods and skin musk. Thornapple is an eau de parfum, edp.
HERETIC PARFUM THORNAPPLE REVIEWS
Fragrantica: "The first several minutes of this fragrance are enticing - it is floral but moody, with an earthy depth from the oakmoss, a soft nondescript fruitiness and a slight camphorous note of cardamom. I do find that the fragrance did not wear well over time on me. Within about 4 hours it was almost undetectable. Over time the fragrance devolved into a flat, almost musty bruised fruit smell. I absolutely see what others are saying about the rotting fruit smell…"
Fragrantica: "This is the most seasonally focused fragrance I own. It should come with a flannel shirt and woolly socks (though Heretic’s packaging IS absolutely stunning). The opening smells like straight apple cider. As it dries down, it takes on a tiny bit of a smoky edge with the beeswax becoming more prominent before settling into a more subdued, wearable, violet-forward scent. It has that very familiar Heretic DNA (iykyk), and it smells very similar to Shadow People after several hours of wear. Longevity is impressive - I get slight whiffs of it into the next day even after showering."
Fragrantica: "The plum/apple accord is suuuper syrupy and thick on initial spray - I do kinda agree with the comments about rotting fruit but it’s not unpleasant, just strong. I was a little worried I was going to give myself a headache because it’s so strong, but as it settles the amber comes through and it gets woodier/muskier, the fruit lingers in the background. A little goes a long way & I can still smell it on my skin hours later after 1 spray. Reminds me of Byredo Bibliotheque but definitely leans more masculine."
Fragrantica: "I’ve been chomping at the bit to get my hands on this one!! First impressions: Super green and dry with an air of peaceful eeriness. It feels like an overcast autumnal day, cold and moody but the sun is still bright through the clouds. Bright apple evaporates off almost immediately on skin, quickly leaving a strong woody camphorous middle(almost like tiger balm or vicks without being strongly minty). About an hour later it settles further into a very musky woody scent. It smelled VERY different on me than it did on my friend, so I’d suspect it’s a very skin-chemistry dependent fragrance. Super fascinating and deeply nostalgic to time spent in yoga studios with my mom as a child. Very interested to see how my smell of this morphs with more wears."
Heretic Parfum: "Bought this scent on a wild whim for something different from my usual scents. I wasn't sure I would love it and was prepared to gift it just in case. There will be no gifting here! I LOVE this scent! It's just the right combination of herbal and fruity that I was looking for. Definitely heavier on the herbaceous scents than the fruity, but that's precisely my preference. Heretic Parfum never ceases to amaze."
Heretic Parfum: "This one is weird! And I say that lovingly. It's got a sour green apple top note that immediately refreshes and awakens, and dries into a green, almost grassy, woodsy floral (with maybe a hint of a powdery note). Really, I don't know how to describe it. To me, it feels like a crisp autumnal day, in an overgrown garden, with just a hint of decay. (And of course, the packaging is stunning, as per usual)."
Heretic Parfum: "I grow and dry lemon verbena for tea and the smell of my dried leaves smells wonderfully smoky, herbal and slightly cirtusy. Mixed with earthy mugwort, its my evening herbal tea. I'm pleasantly surprised that Thornapple has a similar scent, smoky and herbal and earthy, but far deeper and richer, more complex. I do get the apple and dark plum and black tea notes. Its a beautiful scent and lasts a long while on me. Its so different from other Heretic scents. I love how Heretic continually creates acents so different and wonderful. I'll be ordering a full bottle."
Reddit: "I would say it’s heavy on the frankincense on my skin. It’s got a nice spicy scent. I don’t smell any resin or fruity scent at all. It’s almost smoky to me."